Murder Mystery 2
Trade knives, guns, and pets
463 items in catalog
Live listings
Buy now from sellers on Mystery Shop
Item catalog
All known items for Murder Mystery 2. Only items with active listings can be purchased — use the listings section above to buy now.
385–432 of 463 items
Red Seer
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Seer
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Spectral (Gun)
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Santa's Magic
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Santa's Spirit
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Splitter
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Witched
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Blue Elite
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Green Elite
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Blue Pumpkin (2020)
Pet
Value 3
Browse item
Ghosty
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Sparkle1
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Sparkle2
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Sparkle3
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Asteroid
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Slime (Gun)
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Gothic (Gun)
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
![Gingerbread (Gun) [XMAS2019]](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fsupremevalues.com%2Fmedia%2Fmm2uncommons%2FGingerbread_2019_Gun.png&w=3840&q=75)
Gingerbread (Gun) [XMAS2019]
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Webs
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Pumpkin Pie
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Holly (Gun)
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Potion (2017)
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Potion (Gun)
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Jack
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Snakebite (Knife)
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Sun
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Bats
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Monster
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Santa's Magic
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Santa's Spirit
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Ghastly (Gun)
Knife
Value 3
Browse item
Orange Seer
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Yellow Seer
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Traveler (Knife)
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Blue Scratch
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Ghost (Gun)
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Shadow Pumpkin
Pet
Value 2
Browse item
Blue Pumpkin (2019)
Pet
Value 2
Browse item
Slimy
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Grind
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Indy
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Frozen (Knife)
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Mummy (2017)
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Mummy 2018 (Knife)
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Zombie (Knife)
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Ghostfire
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Green Marble
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
Orange Marble
Knife
Value 2
Browse item
385–432 of 463 items